The McNutt Case

The 1868 Home-Distilling Ban Is Headed to the Supreme Court

Home distilling is illegal in Minnesota. Federal law has banned distilling spirits at home since 1868, and it is a federal felony — up to a $10,000 fine and five years in prison. Minnesota law separately requires a license to manufacture spirits. Nothing about the court case below changes that today. This page follows the case; it is information, not legal advice.

What the case is

In Department of Justice v. McNutt (No. 26-204), the Supreme Court will decide whether Congress has the power to ban home distilling at all. The ban (26 U.S.C. § 5178) dates to 1868 and was written as a tax measure. The challengers — backed by the Hobby Distillers Association — argue that a “tax” on an activity Congress has flatly prohibited, which raises no revenue, is not a tax at all, and that the ban exceeds Congress’s power.

  • 2024: A federal judge in Texas struck the ban down as unconstitutional.
  • April 2026: The Fifth Circuit agreed — the ban exceeds Congress’s taxing power. Days later, the Sixth Circuit upheld the ban in a similar case. When appeals courts split like this, the Supreme Court is the tiebreaker.
  • October 19, 2026: The Supreme Court agreed to hear the case. Arguments are expected in early 2027, with a decision likely by late June or early July 2027.
  • Until the Court rules, nothing changes in Minnesota. A lower-court order in the case covers only the named plaintiffs and Hobby Distillers Association members. For everyone else, the ban remains fully in force.

What a ruling each way would mean for Minnesota

The most important fact first: this case is only about making spirits at home for personal use. It does not challenge the permits, inspections, or taxes that apply to licensed distilleries. Minnesota’s distilleries — large and small — would operate under exactly the same rules the day after the decision as the day before, whichever way it goes.

If the ban is struck down:

  • The federal ban falls — but home distilling would still be illegal in Minnesota. State law requires a license to manufacture spirits, and only the Minnesota Legislature can change that. The question would move from the courts to the State Capitol.
  • Commercial distilling is untouched. Licensed distilleries keep their federal permits and pay the same taxes; nothing about the ruling changes what can be sold, or by whom. Spirits made at home could not legally be sold.
  • History suggests a slow, positive ripple for craft distilling. Homebrewing beer and wine was in a similar spot until Congress legalized it in 1978 — and the craft beer industry grew out of that hobbyist base. Hobbyists became craft breweries’ best customers, and some became brewers themselves. A legal home-distilling hobby would likely grow the same kind of knowledgeable, engaged audience for Minnesota’s craft distilleries over time.
  • The biggest immediate commercial effect would not be at distilleries at all, but at the companies that make stills and home equipment.

If the ban is upheld:

  • Nothing changes. Home distilling remains a federal felony and illegal in Minnesota, full stop. A handful of other states have passed laws allowing home distilling; those laws would remain inoperative under the federal ban.
  • Licensed distilleries continue exactly as today.

Either way: the decision will land in the middle of 2027, and if the ban falls, the real Minnesota debate — what state law should say — starts then. The Guild will follow it here.

Follow the case

Follow the case. The Supreme Court hears arguments in early 2027 and is expected to rule by early summer. Sign up and we’ll email you at each milestone — the argument, the decision, and what it means for Minnesota. No noise, no spam; just the case.

Subscribe

* indicates required

Why the Guild is following this

The Minnesota Distillers Guild represents licensed Minnesota distilleries. This case is the biggest legal question in American distilling in a generation, and its outcome will shape the debate about distilling law in Minnesota for years. We’ll keep this page current as the case moves.

Minnesota Distillers Guild

Minnesota Distillers Guild
Local Spirits • Stronger Communities • A Brighter Minnesota